History writer: Jesus probably never existed — here’s why Christianity emerged anyway
Apr15

History writer: Jesus probably never existed — here’s why Christianity emerged anyway

  With Easter coming, some people are debating whether the resurrection of Jesus really happened. Others are debating whether Jesus was even real. In ten years of writing for news and opinion sites, my most popular article about religion was one titled, “Five Reasons to Suspect Jesus Never Existed.” The article emerged from a conversation with history writer David Fitzgerald and was based on his book, Nailed. Fitzgerald holds the controversial perspective that the figure of Jesus at the heart of Christianity is historicized mythology, meaning that the original kernel was a set of ancient religious tropes or myths that got historical details added as they were told and retold by people who believed them to be real. By contrast, best-selling New Testament scholar Bart Ehrman (and most secular historians and mainline Christian theologians) argue that an actual radical rabbi provided the kernel of the stories, but that accounts of his life then got overlaid with fragments of mythology drawn from Judaism and surrounding religions. In other words, they hold that the Bible stories are mythologized history. The third perspective, of course, is that held by many (though not all) Christians—that the gospel stories are gospel truth.  Outsiders can debate all they want, but Christians need to believe that Jesus was real, and defenders of the faith line up a series of proofs that they claim settle the question. Now Fitzgerald has produced a three-volume set, Jesus: Mything in Action, in which he tackles those proofs one by one and then lays out how Christianity could have emerged even in the absence of a historical Jesus. Tarico: What first made you wonder if, perhaps, Jesus never existed? Fitzgerald: It’s funny; for the first thirty-five years of my life, the very idea that there might not have been a real Jesus never occurred to me. Ironically enough, it wasn’t until I became curious to know what Jesus really said and did that I began to seriously look at our evidence for Jesus. That‘s when the doubts set in. At first, I just wanted to figure out which parts of the gospels were later legendary add-ons. Over time I became increasingly convinced that Jesus himself is a completely mythical figure of the early Christians. That led me to write Nailed. Tarico: What are a couple of the key points that took you from that first wild, trippy thought—Whoa, what if Jesus never existed?—to your current position, that he probably didn’t. Fitzgerald: Honestly, I’d put it even more strongly than that – now, I actually can’t see how there even could have been an actual Jesus. The first red flag for me was realizing just how...

Read More
Couchoud’s The Creation of Christ uploaded (by Rene Salm)
Dec04

Couchoud’s The Creation of Christ uploaded (by Rene Salm)

  I am pleased to notify readers that I have uploaded to this website the English translation of Paul-Louis Couchoud’s seminal work The Creation of Christ: An Outline of the Beginnings of Christianity (1939; original French edition: Jésus, Le Dieu fait Homme, 1937). By Rene Salm The expert translation was executed by C. Bradlaugh Bonner and is in two volumes (229 and 241 pages), each in a separate PDF. I would like to thank Frank Zindler for making the digital translation on two CDs available to me, and also for graciously allowing me to put this important work of Jesus mythicism before the general public. The two PDF’s can be downloaded at the links below and also from the onsite introductory page on P. L. Couchoud. The French mythicist Georges Ory summarized Couchoud’s view regarding Jesus: The history of Jesus is the history of the formation of Jesus. It enters the human psyche as do all divine histories, by agreement, council, and fiat. Jesus was declared a historical personage by the ardent outworkings of faith, outworkings whose traces cannot be found before the second century of our era. Jesus is a being constructed by consensus. Such constructed beings are properly termed divinities… [Jesus] was birthed by a cult, grew up with it, did not become god but was so from the start—a savior god, a heavenly king… The true historian of Jesus is not a historicist. He knows how to distinguish facts from ideas which use facts. Jesus is the source only of sterility and irritation when seen from the historicist perspective. That Jesus will reward enquirers with infinite frustration. Such, in the main, was the conception of Paul-Louis Couchoud. (G. Ory, article on Couchoud in the the Dictionnaire Rationaliste of 1964, my translation.) The Creation of Christ, vol. 1 (1.1 MB)               The Creation of Christ, vol. 2 (1.7 MB) Neil Godfrey also offers the entire book in segments (scanned from the hardcopy), with his comments, beginning here.  ...

Read More
Josephus & The Jesus Forgeries (by Michael Sherlock)
Aug29

Josephus & The Jesus Forgeries (by Michael Sherlock)

  In Memory of D.M. Murdock   Josephus was an elite Jew, born in Jerusalem a few years after Jesus’ alleged crucifixion.  He served as a Jewish military leader in Galilee, the very place alleged to have been home to Jesus.  Josephus’ father, Matthais, was of Jewish royalty and lived during the alleged life of Jesus, in Jerusalem, the very town in which many of Jesus’ main events were supposed to have transpired.  It is curious that Josephus’ father never mentioned a miracle worker by the name of Jesus of Nazareth.  Josephus was also a Jewish historian who penned voluminous works on Jewish history.  Two of his most renowned works were the ‘Antiquities of the Jews’ and ‘The Jewish Wars.’  From these works it is plain to see that despite his desire for self-preservation, he was a very proud and devout Jew. Before we begin to examine the two alleged references to Jesus which appear in his work entitled ‘Antiquity of the Jews’ (90CE~94CE), it is both relevant and necessary to note that within his ‘Antiquities of the Jews,’ he made mention of approximately twenty different people named Jesus. Some of these characters included Jesus the son of Sapphias, Jesus the son of Gamala, Jesus the son of Phabet, Jesus the son of Sie, Jesus the son of Fabus, Jesus the son of Thias, Jesus the son of Gamaliel, Jesus the son of Damneus, Jesus the brother of Onias, Jesus the brother of John, Jesus the Galilean, who was a great military commander, and numerous others. Josephus – The Jew Given that we know Josephus remained a devout Jew for the entire span of his life, we should take a quick look at the Jewish belief regarding the coming messiah.   Judaism, whether pharisaic or orthodox, rejects the notion that the Christian’s Jesus was the Messiah/Christ. A prominent Jewish website enunciates the Jewish belief regarding the future arrival of the messiah, saying: “Belief in the eventual coming of the ‘moshiach’ (messiah)… is part of the minimum requirements of Jewish belief.  In the ‘Shemoneh Esrei’ prayer, recited three times daily, we pray for all of the elements of the coming of the moshiach: gathering of the exiles; restoration of the religious courts of justice; an end of wickedness, sin, and heresy; reward to the righteous; rebuilding of Jerusalem; restoration of the line of King David; and restoration of Temple service.”(1) Furthermore, Judaism has certain scriptural requirements for the coming messiah which have yet to be fulfilled. What is the Messiah supposed to accomplish? The Hebrew Bible says that he will: Build the Third Temple (Ezekiel 37:26-28). Gather all Jews back to the Land of Israel (Isaiah 43:5-6). Usher in...

Read More
Kenneth Humphreys’ thoughts about the 1st Panhellenic Mythicist Conference
May31

Kenneth Humphreys’ thoughts about the 1st Panhellenic Mythicist Conference

    What an honour to have been a guest speaker at the First Panhellenic Mythicist Conference, held in May 2016! This was a well-organised conference held in the prestigious Athens Cultural Centre, with a dozen excellent speakers from diverse academic and research backgrounds and speaking on a wide range of mythicist topics. The Greeks are justifiably proud of their cultural heritage of myth, one of their many gifts to civilisation, and not lost even if obscured by centuries of religious Orthodoxy. Greek Mythicists are far from being stridently anti-Christian but the contribution they are able to make in exposing the falsification of the tales of Jesus from the myths of ancient Greece is without equal. A Jewish corpse Jesus may be but he is a corpse clothed in the myths of ancient Greece. by Kenneth Humphreys, jesusneverexisted.com A public transport strike did not deter a good attendance at the conference, and the audience remained engaged for eight long hours of detailed and informed erudition. I had the services of two excellent translators. The presentations began with a consideration of ubiquitous solar myths and symbolism (profs. Stephanos Paipetis, Radamanthys Anastasakis) and the shift from the collective discovery of knowledge to the restrictive “prophetic revelation” and symbolic hero-types typical of religion. It moved through a closer consideration of the myths of Genesis and female subordination (Harita Meenee) to the emergence of the “divine mother and child” archetype (Stratos Theodosiou) and the later development of a “virgin assumed into heaven” (George Ioannidis). Discussion moved on to the subsuming of myth into the faux historicity of Christianity (Christos Panopoulos). Pre-Christian religion was shown to have profoundly influenced Christian rituals, in dance, music and voice (Ioannis Mpousiou). Antecedents to the cross were identified in Orphic archetypes (Evrinomi Gavra). Doubts as to the historicity of Jesus were expressed very early by Neoplatonists (George Gousgounis). In my own talk, I presented the worldwide dimension to Jesus mythicism and a broad-brush introduction to mythicist arguments – expertly rendered into Greek by Marietta Simegiatou. Interludes were provided by short videos of encouragement from notable mythicists (Mythicists Milwaukee, Raphael Lataster, David Fitzgerald, Richard Carrier) and an interesting talk on fire walking (George Lekakis-Eleni Koulizaki). “Q and A” had a curious Greek twist. Apparently in Greek tradition members of the audience are allowed to make their own statements or “interventions”. No actual question is necessary. In the “less democratic” English tradition such indulgences are frowned upon! Minas Papageorgiou, is author of Jesus Mythicism: An Introduction, a compilation from mythicist writers, which has helped fellow Greeks perceive the essentially artificial character of Jesus. Minas is to be commended for his drive and energy in...

Read More
Golden Dawn party attempts to shut down Mythicism Conference
May26

Golden Dawn party attempts to shut down Mythicism Conference

  On May 18th the Golden Dawn party attempted a brazen intervention on the democratically founded right of Greek Citizens to express their opinions in public (in this case the fruits of their scholarly endeavours) just 4 days before the 1st Panhellenic Conference on Mythicism was to take place at the Community Centre of the Municipality of Athens. Ilias Panagiotaros, MP of the far right party, sent a letter to the Ministry of Education requesting that the Conference be canceled, since -as he put it- it aims to “destroy the faith of Greeks” (!). We’d rather not comment on the fact that Mr. Panagiotaros is ignorant on the nature of the scholarly field of Mythicism, which is neither a religion nor a philosophical path, but a field of study open to anyone, believer and non-believer alike, nor on the fact that he confused the city of Milwaukee (and the local mythicist organization) with… Oklahoma. It appears that Golden Dawn has yet another reason to dislike Milwaukee, other than the participation of the successful Greek basketball player Giannis Antetokounmpo in the local NBA team. On our part, we ask the friends and visitors of our website to consider the fate of all our free-thinking peers who publicly express their opinions and ideas in case these people ever get any real power. Since, for the time being, that scenario is science fiction, let’s take a moment to appreciate the democratic rights we enjoy as a society… Greek Mythicists – 25/5/2016   The following is the letter of the Golden Dawn MP, Ilias Panagiotaros. TO: MINISTRY OF EDUCATION, RESEARCH AND RELIGIOUS AFFAIRS SUBJECT: “Panhellenic Conference of Mythicists in Athens” The Mayor of Athens, G. Kaminis, granted the use of the “Antonis Tritsis” hall of the Municipality of Athens Community Centre to the organization of Mythicists, so they can organize their first panhellenic conference, with international participation and Mr. Stratos Theodosiou as the keynote speaker (President of the Union of Greek Physicists and Deputy Professor of the University of Athens). This conference will support the idea that Christ is a mythological figure and never existed historically. Participation is free of charge and will take place on May 22nd, 2016. The competent minister is being asked: 1) Does the Ministry have knowledge of this panhellenic greek mythicist conference (in collaboration with the relevant Oklahoma USA mythicist department) with the topic that Christ never existed historically and is a mythological figure alone? 2) The Greek Constitution stated that the Orthodox Christian Faith is the dominant religion of our homeland. How can the ministry protect protect the holies of 2000 years of our homeland, if it...

Read More
All the Gods That Rose From the Dead in Spring Before Jesus Christ (Garrett Griffin)
Mar27

All the Gods That Rose From the Dead in Spring Before Jesus Christ (Garrett Griffin)

  In the same way many ancient Mediterranean societies told tales of gods born to virgins(some on December 25) before the time of Christ, the archetype of gods rising from the dead is likewise older than Christianity, an uncomfortable historical fact for many religious people but not necessarily unforeseeable given the power of human imagination and the long stretch of human history before the Common Era (or Anno Domini, A.D., if you prefer). By Garrett Griffin In human religion, gods often die and return to life, sometimes in their old form, sometimes in a new one (see All About Adam and Eve, Richard Gillooly, and Godless, Dan Barker). They also often came to earth disguised as mortals, especially in Greek and Hindu myths. Dionysus was killed, descended into hell, and was reborn — in Zeus’ thigh of all places. Greek gods, goddesses, and mortals often descended into hell for various reasons and later rejoined the living. Demeter’s daughter, Persephone, descended into Hades and returned in the spring. Attis, a Phrygian-Greek vegetation god born of the virgin Nana, castrated himself and, depending on the version, either bled to death from this or was hanged on a pine tree. He was reborn after three days, his blood redeeming the earth as it fell from his body. His worshipers celebrated the salvation from death offered to them by Attis by decorating a pine tree each spring. This took place on March 25, a date later used by Christians for the Easter celebration (while no longer used for Easter, Catholics still use it to celebrate the Feast of Annunciation of the Blessed Virgin Mary). In Egypt, Osiris died, was resurrected, and ascended into heaven. Horus came back from the dead. Like many gods related to vegetation, Adonis, worshiped in Babylonia and Syria as early as the 7th century B.C., died annually (in the fall) and was resurrected (in the spring). In Greece, Heracles was mortal but rose into heaven to take his place among the gods just before he died. In Hindu mythology, Shiva cut off Ganesha’s head but Pavarti convinced him to bring the god back to life. Krishna is accidentally killed by a hunter, but comes back to life and ascends into heaven. The Sumerian king Tammuz was killed but resurrected by the gods and made a god himself. According to the Mesoamerican people, Quetzalcoatl killed himself, but after a few days in the underworld returned to heaven. Then there’s Mithra, made the “Protector of the Empire” by the Romans in 307 AD, right before Christianity was declared the official religion, but actually a Person god worshipped before 200 B.C. Some versions of Mithra’s story make...

Read More